Brief, mostly facts
A five-agent investor panel barely beats always saying no
The panel scored 84 percent on 100 TV investor decisions. An always-pass baseline scored 83 percent, and the panel made 5 offers versus 17 real ones.
What the research found
A Reddit builder's five-subagent investor review panel scored 84% against 100 TV-show investor decisions, only one point above an always-pass baseline at 83%, and made 5 offers versus 17 real ones.
Claims and how well the evidence supports them
- Panel with scoring rules matched real investor decisions 84% of 100 decisions 98%
- Always-pass baseline scored 83% 99%
- Panel made 5 offers where real investors made 17 99%
- Offers were missed on pitches with average scores 2.2 to 4.8 where offer needs 6.5 99%
Evidence
- reddit.com https://reddit.com/r/ClaudeAI/comments/1xbp086/we_tested_our_fiveagent_review_panel_against_100
Actionability rated low.